Veterinary clinical trials and human clinical trials share some similarities, but there are key differences owing to the distinct nature of the subjects involved—animals versus humans. Here are several factors that differentiate veterinary clinical trials from human clinical trials:
- Purpose and Objectives:
Veterinary Trials: Primarily focus on testing and developing treatments, drugs, or medical devices for animal health. The aim is to improve the well-being of animals, enhance veterinary medicine, and contribute to public health (e.g., by evaluating food safety or zoonotic diseases).
Human Trials: Aim to assess the safety and efficacy of treatments, drugs, or medical devices for human health. The ultimate goal is to gain regulatory approval for human use.
- Informed Consent:
Veterinary Trials: Relies on the consent of the animal owners or caregivers, who act as proxies for the animals.
Human Trials: Requires informed consent directly from the human participants or their legal representatives.
- Regulatory Oversight:
Veterinary Trials: Regulatory oversight varies by country, and the regulations are generally less stringent compared to those for human trials. In many cases, veterinary trials are regulated by animal welfare authorities.
Human Trials: Subject to rigorous oversight by health authorities (e.g., FDA in the United States, EMA in Europe) and ethics committees to ensure participant safety and ethical conduct.
- Trial Design:
Veterinary Trials: Often involve field trials with naturally occurring diseases in animals. The study design may be more flexible, reflecting the diversity of animal species and conditions.
Human Trials: Typically follow a more standardized and controlled design, with defined phases (Phase I to Phase IV) to assess safety, efficacy, and long-term effects.
- Medical Coding:
Veterinary Trials: Veterinary clinical trials involve the use of coding systems specifically designed for animals, recognizing the differences in anatomy, physiology, and diseases.
Examples of Coding Dictionaries:
- VetDRA (Veterinary Dictionary for Drug Regulatory Activities): Developed for coding veterinary medical events and terms. It is analogous to MedDRA but adapted for veterinary use.
- ATCvet (Anatomical Therapeutic Chemical Veterinary): Used for the classification of veterinary medicinal products, similar to the WHO Drug Dictionary but tailored for animals.
- SNOMED CT Veterinary Extension: An extension of SNOMED CT (Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine – Clinical Terms) specifically designed for veterinary medicine, covering a wide range of clinical concepts and relationships.
Human Trials: Human clinical trials primarily use coding systems that are specific to human medical conditions and interventions. Examples of Coding Dictionaries:
- MedDRA (Medical Dictionary for Regulatory Activities): Widely used for coding adverse events and medical history in human clinical trials. It provides a standardized vocabulary for reporting medical information.
- WHO Drug Dictionary: Utilized for coding and classifying medicinal products in a standardized manner.
- ICD (International Classification of Diseases): Commonly used for coding diseases, health conditions, and related factors. It is a fundamental tool in health information systems globally.
- Endpoints and Outcomes:
Veterinary Trials: Endpoints may include improvement in clinical signs, quality of life, or survival. Outcomes are often assessed based on observable changes in the animal’s health.
Human Trials: Endpoints vary based on the phase of the trial but commonly include clinical endpoints (e.g., reduction in symptoms, increased survival), surrogate endpoints, or biomarkers.
- Sample Size and Statistical Considerations:
Veterinary Trials: Sample sizes may be smaller due to the availability of eligible animals. Statistical considerations can be influenced by variability in animal breeds, ages, and conditions.
Human Trials: Larger sample sizes are typically required to ensure statistical power and representativeness. Rigorous statistical methodologies are employed to draw meaningful conclusions.
- Data Collection and Analysis:
Veterinary Trials: Data collection may involve a combination of clinical observations, laboratory tests, and owner-reported information.
Human Trials: Collect data through standardized clinical assessments, imaging, laboratory tests, and patient-reported outcomes. Rigorous statistical analyses are applied to assess the significance of findings.
- Placebo Use:
Veterinary Trials: Placebo-controlled trials are less common, and ethical considerations may limit their use in veterinary medicine.
Human Trials: Placebo-controlled trials are frequently employed, especially in early-phase studies, to assess the true effect of an intervention.
Understanding these differences is crucial for researchers, clinicians, and regulatory bodies to conduct ethical, scientifically rigorous, and effective clinical trials in both veterinary and human contexts.
Cloudbyz Unified Clinical Trial Management (CTMS) is a comprehensive, integrated solution to streamline clinical trial operations. Built on the Salesforce cloud platform, our CTMS provides real-time visibility and analytics across study planning, budgeting, start-up, study management, and close-out. Cloudbyz CTMS can help you achieve greater efficiency, compliance, and quality in your clinical operations with features like automated workflows, centralized data management, and seamless collaboration. Contact us today to learn how Cloudbyz CTMS can help your organization optimize its clinical trial management processes.
To know more about the Cloudbyz Unified Clinical Trial Management Solution contact info@cloudbyz.com
